
Microsoft's WMV DRM (Digital Restrictions Management)
Preamble: Copyrighted content should be respected, and the creater should be paid recognised for his or her work. However,
if there's any doubt as to the morality of DRM, please read
"The Customer Is Always Wrong" by the EFF. It's not illegal to
circumvent or remove DRM, in the same way that you can disable cd protections to make a personal backup; this
is "Fair Use", depending on which country you're in.
Digital Music: I buy all my music legally from Emusic and
AllofMP3 because it's fairly priced; most people prefer good quality,
cheap content to variable quality, free content. Digital music providers who use DRM (eg. iTunes) are rapidly
loosing market share to these non-DRM providers
(see Xtn Data's report on this).
Digital Video: There's no equivalent movie download service; all the ones I've seen so far provide
DRM content using Microsoft's apalling unportable WMV format. So have to pay multiple times to own (not
to rent or to purchase limited rights) for the same content which I watch on a wide variety of devices using a
wide variety of software.
Case Study: BT Vision.
Let's look at the value proposition for an example movie (Jarhead):
Un-DRM: I'm not suggesting anyone should purchase from BT Vision (continue to download for free via
Bittorrent, and buy the physical DVD if you can
find it in a store) but if you must, then here's how to disable the DRM.
Further reading:
So, for more than twice the price, you get a lower quality, restricted version? Add to that this "service"
is available only in the UK, and you have to download and install BT's "Vision Player" - who would want that?
With no fair alternative, no wonder people are just downloading the DVD for free.
Amazon.co.uk BT Vision
Price
GBP 8 (EUR 12)
GBP 17 (EUR 25)
Quality
9.8 Mbit/s MPEG-2 video
1.6 Mbit/s WMV video
Restrictions
None
Can only play using Windows Media Player 10+
Can only play if connected to the Internet
Compatability /
Portability
Compatable with anything;
Portable to anything
Plays on a limited selection of platforms;
Cannot convert
You can download all of the above in a single archive
here [23 MB]. Please let me know if you
have any problems or comments.
[4.6 MB]
For some reason, the install requires a password: it's "mayang".
[4.6 MB]